#18 More than just Expertise: The 5 Leadership Skills that set top CISOs apart

How top CISOs can set themselves apart from the rest

Greetings, and welcome to Digital Leadership Excellence—your trusted weekly guide to excelling in tech leadership, delivering results, and thriving with clarity and purpose. In every issue, we provide insights into winning strategies, growth tactics, and practical solutions, designed to support both current and aspiring technology leaders navigating the ever-evolving digital world.

1.0 First Things First…

Let me start with a truth that might sting a little.

Your technical expertise? It's not enough anymore.

SHOCKING, right? After all, you've built your entire career on technical excellence. But here's what I've learned after working with hundreds of security leaders:

The skills that got you to the CISO role aren't the ones that will make you successful in it.

Quick story...

How many times have you listened to a highly technical CISO present at a board meeting. His knowledge of security frameworks? Impeccable. His understanding of threat landscapes? Outstanding.

But he was losing the room. Fast.

Why? Because he was missing the fundamental leadership skills that transform security leaders into business executives.

2.0 What You Need

Today, I'm pulling back the curtain on these skills. Not just what they are, but exactly how to develop them. Let's dive in...

2.1 Business Fluency: Speaking the Language of Impact

Remember that CISO in the board meeting? His breakthrough came when he stopped talking about threats and started talking about risk and revenue impact.

Here's how to develop this skill:

  • Translate every security metric into business terms

  • Learn your company's revenue model inside out

  • Connect security initiatives to business objectives

  • Practice explaining complex issues to non-technical stakeholders

Action Step: Before your next presentation, ask yourself: "How would I explain this to the CFO?"

2.2 Emotional Intelligence: The Crisis Management Superpower

In today's threat landscape, incidents are inevitable. But how you handle them? That's what sets you apart.

Example: Two CISOs faced identical ransomware attempts. The first created panic, sending 3 AM emails and stressing out their team. The second? They maintained composure, set clear priorities, and actually increased board confidence during the crisis.

The difference? Emotional intelligence.

Key components to develop:

  • Self-awareness during high-stress situations

  • Reading and managing team emotions

  • Adjusting communication style based on context

  • Building trust through consistent behavior

Action Step: Start a "pressure journal" - document how you respond in high-stress situations.

2.3 Executive Presence: The Trust Amplifier

Here's a hard truth: People decide whether to trust your security program based on how you show up as a leader.

I recently worked with a CISO who transformed his entire security program's reputation without changing a single technical control. How?

He mastered executive presence through:

  • Confident (not arrogant) communication

  • Consistent calm under pressure

  • Strategic questioning instead of defensive responses

  • Authentic relationship building

Action Step: Record yourself in your next team meeting. Watch it back. Are you projecting the presence you want?

2.4 Strategic Influence: The Power to Drive Change

Here's a hard truth: People decide whether to trust your security program based on how you show up as a leader.

I recently worked with a CISO who transformed his entire security program's reputation without changing a single technical control. How?

He mastered executive presence through:

  • Confident (not arrogant) communication

  • Consistent calm under pressure

  • Strategic questioning instead of defensive responses

  • Authentic relationship building

Action Step: Record yourself in your next team meeting. Watch it back. Are you projecting the presence you want?

2.5 Adaptive Leadership: The Future-Proofing Factor

Here's the reality of security leadership today: What works now won't work next year. What seems impossible today will be mandatory tomorrow.

The final skill that sets top CISOs apart? Their ability to adapt and evolve.

I recently watched a security leader navigate the sudden need for zero-trust architecture. Instead of resisting or rushing, they:

  • Created a learning culture in their team

  • Experimented with pilot programs

  • Embraced feedback and adjusted course

  • Maintained vision while being flexible on approach

Action Step: Schedule monthly "future-scanning" sessions with your team.

3.0 Putting it all together

Here's your roadmap for developing these skills:

3.1 Assess Your Current State

  • Where are you strongest?

  • Where do you need growth?

  • What's the biggest gap between where you are and where you want to be?

3.2 Choose Your Focus Area

  • Start with the skill that will have the biggest immediate impact

  • Create specific development goals

  • Find opportunities to practice in your current role

3.3 Build Your Support System

  • Find a mentor who exemplifies these skills

  • Seek feedback from trusted colleagues

  • Consider working with a coach who specializes in security leadership

3.4 Track Your Progress

  • Document your leadership wins

  • Note areas of continued challenge

  • Celebrate small improvements

4.0 The Bottom Line

Technical expertise got you here. Leadership skills will take you where you want to go.

Ready to transform your leadership impact?

Here's your first challenge: Pick ONE of these skills. Focus on it for the next 30 days. Document your progress.

Drop a comment below with which skill you're choosing. Let's grow together.

Want to dive deeper? DM me for access to my CISO Leadership Assessment Tool.

Remember: Every great security leader started exactly where you are now.

The only question is: What will you do next?

Robert Castle 
Founder | DIGITAL LEADERSHIP EXCELLENCE

Reply

or to participate.