#63 The Integrity Illusion: The Career Cost of confusing Integrity with Invisibility

Let me tell you about two Directors I worked with way back.

Both brilliant. Both delivered exceptional results. Both had teams that would follow them anywhere.

One is now a CIO making $400K. The other is still a Director at $180K.

Same technical skills. Same leadership abilities. Same integrity.

So what was the difference?

The CIO understood something the Director refused to accept. Visibility isn't optional. Advocacy isn't selling out. And staying invisible in the name of integrity is just fear wearing a virtue badge.

The Director called it "not playing politics." But what he was really doing was avoiding the vulnerability of being known. Of being wrong.  The risk of rejection. The discomfort of building relationships with executives who could actually influence his career.

He convinced himself this made him more principled. More authentic. More focused on what mattered.

But here's what actually happened.

His budget got cut every year because nobody at the executive level understood the value of what his team built. His strategic ideas died in email chains because he never put himself in rooms where decisions got made. His team watched opportunities go to other departments because their leader refused to advocate for them.

And when promotion time came? He wasn't even considered. Because to get promoted to executive levels, people need to know you exist.

The painful irony is that his silence didn't protect anything. It just made him irrelevant.

I see this pattern constantly in technology leadership. Smart, capable, principled leaders who confuse invisibility with integrity. Who believe that advocating for themselves somehow compromises their values.

But that belief is built on false assumptions.

Assumption one is that visibility requires manipulation. It doesn't. Having regular conversations with your CEO about strategic initiatives isn't playing politics. It's leadership.

Assumption two is that sharing wins equals bragging. It doesn't. Letting executives know how your technology investments drove business outcomes isn't arrogance. It's communication.

Assumption three is that relationship building is fake. It isn't. Getting to know peers across the business so you can collaborate effectively isn't schmoozing. It's how organizations actually work.

The technology leaders who advance to executive roles understand this. They build genuine relationships. They make their strategic thinking visible. They advocate for their teams and their work.

Not because they're less principled. Because they understand that influence is how you create change.

Think about what happens when you stay invisible. Your team needs budget for critical infrastructure upgrades. But when the CFO asks what technology investments drive revenue, your name never comes up. Someone else gets that budget.

Your organization is making a major platform decision. But you've never built relationships with the executives driving that choice. Your expertise doesn't factor into their thinking.

A VP role opens up. But the CEO doesn't know your strategic capabilities because you've never made yourself visible. Someone less qualified gets the job because they were simply known.

This is the real cost of hiding behind integrity. Not to your ego. To your impact.

Every time you choose invisibility over advocacy, you're making a decision. Not just for yourself, but for everyone counting on you to show up. Your team needs an advocate who can fight for resources. Your organization needs your strategic perspective in the room where decisions happen.

And yes, you deserve compensation that reflects your actual value. But none of that is possible from the shadows.

The question you need to ask yourself is hard. Are you actually protecting your integrity? Or are you protecting yourself from the discomfort of being visible?

Because real integrity doesn't mean staying quiet. It means stepping into the full weight of your leadership responsibility. Even when it's uncomfortable. Even when it feels vulnerable. Even when you might make a mistake. Even when part of you just wants to put your head down and do the work.

That comfort you're protecting? It's costing you everything you say you want.

So what does authentic advocacy actually look like?

It starts with understanding that influence isn't a dirty word. It's the currency of executive leadership.

You can't drive strategic change without it. You can't protect your team without it. You can't advance to C-suite roles without it.

And you can't build it from behind a wall of false principles.

Here's what changes when you stop hiding.

First, you start having regular conversations with executives about business outcomes. Not technology features. Not system architecture. Business outcomes.

What does that sound like? Instead of "We migrated to the cloud," you say "The cloud migration reduced our customer onboarding time by 40%, which directly contributed to our Q4 revenue growth."

You're translating technical achievement into business language. That's not manipulation. That's communication.

Second, you build relationships before you need them. You don't wait until you need budget approval to start talking to the CFO. You invest time understanding what keeps your peer executives up at night.

What does that look like? Having coffee with your CMO to understand their customer acquisition challenges. Asking your COO about operational bottlenecks. Learning what metrics your CEO actually cares about.

Third, you make your strategic thinking visible in real time. You don't wait for the annual review to share your perspective. You speak up in leadership meetings. You write strategic memos. You ensure decision makers understand how technology shapes business outcomes.

What does that require? Confidence that your perspective matters. Willingness to be wrong sometimes. Courage to challenge assumptions even when it's uncomfortable.

None of this requires compromising your values. All of it requires stepping past your fear.

The technology leaders who master this don't suddenly become different people. They just stop letting discomfort dictate their decisions.

They accept that advocacy is leadership. That visibility is responsibility. That building influence is how you create the change you claim to want.

And here's what happens when they make that shift.

Their teams get the resources they need. Their strategic ideas shape organizational direction. Their compensation reflects their value. And they advance to roles where their impact multiplies.

Not because they sold out. Because they showed up.

Look, I understand the resistance to all of this. Technology leaders often got where they are by being the smartest person in the room. By solving complex problems. By delivering when others couldn't.

That creates a belief system. The belief that merit alone should be enough. That results should speak for themselves. That the best work should naturally rise to the top.

But that's not how organizations work. Organizations are human systems. They promote people they know, trust, and understand. They allocate resources based on relationships and perceived value.

You can argue that shouldn't be true. You can insist it's unfair. You can dig in on principle and refuse to adapt.

Or you can accept reality and learn to operate within it without compromising who you are.

The choice is yours. But the cost of the first path is clear.

You'll work harder than the person who got promoted instead of you. You'll deliver better results. You'll have more integrity, more discipline, more technical excellence.

And you'll still be stuck. Still frustrated. Still invisible.

Because you chose comfort over influence. And you called it integrity.

The alternative requires courage. Courage to be visible even when it feels vulnerable. Courage to build relationships even when it feels uncomfortable. Courage to advocate for yourself and your team even when part of you screams that you shouldn't have to.

But that courage is exactly what executive leadership demands.

So stop hiding behind false principles. Stop using integrity as an excuse for invisibility. Stop letting fear make decisions while you convince yourself it's something nobler.

Your team needs you visible. Your organization needs your strategic thinking. And you deserve the influence, impact, and compensation that should come with the value you create.

But none of that happens until you step out of the shadows and own your full leadership responsibility.

The integrity question isn't whether you should advocate for yourself. It's whether you're willing to show up as the leader everyone needs you to be.

Robert

Robert Castle 

Founder | DIGITAL LEADERSHIP EXCELLENCE

Follow me on LinkedIn

Join the IT Leadership Excellence Network on LinkedIn